Scrutiny

The role of our Scrutiny Committees is to look at the services and issues that affect the lives of people in the Vale of Glamorgan.

It's all about listening to local people, challenging and influencing decision-making and, where necessary, seeking improvement for the benefit of the public.

Scrutiny is a key part of the Council's political structure and plays an important role in ensuring that the Council's services are delivered effectively, efficiently and in the interests of residents and those who work or visit the Vale of Glamorgan.

• What is scrutiny?
  The Local Government Act 2000 required all local authorities to review existing / introduce revised decision–making arrangements. The purpose behind the legislation was to reform and modernise the way local authorities operate, streamline decision-making, ensure elected members are more visible and accountable and improve services.

   

  The Vale of Glamorgan Council adopted a Leader and Cabinet style system with Scrutiny Committees established to advise on policy formulation and hold the Executive ( Cabinet ) to account.

   

  • Scrutiny and Cabinet Roles and Responsibilities

   

• Where does Overview and Scrutiny fit in?
  There are four elements to the governance and management of the Vale of Glamorgan Council:

   

  1. The Cabinet, which is made up of the Leader and six other Cabinet Portfolio Holder Members who have collective responsibility for the executive decisions of the Council and who together form the Council's Cabinet.

   

  2. Overview and Scrutiny which is undertaken by non-executive Members of the Council and is managed through Scrutiny Committees.

   

  3. Regulatory Committees which include Planning, Licensing, Appeals and Appointment Committees.

   

  4. The day-to-day management of the Council, which is the responsibility of the Managing Director and Directors who collectively form the Council's Corporate Management Team.

   

  Members who are not in the Cabinet are charged with keeping an overview of Council business and scrutinising areas of particular interest or concern. Their role includes holding Cabinet to account and assisting in the development and review of Council policy. The latter task involves looking in detail at areas of service delivery or issues of general concern and making recommendations to Cabinet or to the whole Council - this could include suggestions for improvements or different ways of doing things. Members can do this under the normal Call-In or Request for Consideration procedures.

   

  The Scrutiny process provides opportunities for Members of the Council to examine the services provided, and to ask questions on how decisions have been made, to consider whether service improvements can be put in place and to make recommendations accordingly.

• Who sits on a Scrutiny Committee? 

  Scrutiny Committees are made up from Councillors who are not on the Cabinet.  These Committees are able to influence decisions that are taken by the Cabinet and to ensure that the views and needs of the community are taken into account.  

   

  There are 10 Elected Members (Councillors) on each of the Scrutiny Committees.  Please use the buttons below to see the current Committee Memberships and/or Councillor contact details:

   

  • Current Committee Memberships
  • Councillor Contact Details
• What is a Scrutiny Task and Finish Review? 
  
  

  Reviews in the Vale are undertaken by means of either a desk top review, a full in-depth review or a task and finish review and are supported by officers from Democratic and Scrutiny Services and the Improvement and Development Team.

   

  • Scrutiny Review

   

• How can I become involved in Scrutiny? 

  Scrutiny provides the opportunity for the public to become involved in the Council's activities. There is provision for public speaking and to provide written representations at a Scrutiny Committee meeting. Further information is included in the Council's Guide on Public Participation.

   

  If you wish to speak at a Scrutiny Committee you are required to register in advance of the meeting.

   

  • Register to Speak at Corporate Performance and Resources
  • Register to Speak at Environment and Regeneration
  • Register to Speak at Healthy Living and Social Care

  • Register to Speak at Home and Safe Communities
  • Register to Speak at Learning and Culture

   

   

  You can request a service area or matter to be considered by Scrutiny Committee (in line with the procedure outlined below), this could be an issue where there is likely to be an improvement for local people.

   

  If you wish to submit a request, please complete the Scrutiny Review Topic Suggestion form or contact the Democratic and Scrutiny Services Section. 

   

   

  The Scrutiny Committees will be unable to consider any issue that is already subject to internal review/consideration by the Council or external review by an external body.

   

  It is also important that you are aware that matters relating to specific cases falling within the Council's Complaints Procedure and individual disciplinary/grievance matters are also outside the remit of the Scrutiny Committees.

   

  Should the Committee agree to consider the matter you will be advised of the process that will be undertaken and the date of the meeting.

   

  To improve the way Scrutiny engages with the public and stakeholders, the Council has adopted Participation Cymru's 10 Principles for Public Engagement.

   

• Can I attend a Scrutiny meeting and where are they held? 

  All meetings are open to the public unless confidential matters are being discussed.  If a matter is confidential it will be labelled as so on the agenda front sheet.

   

  Meetings are usually held at the Civic Offices, but meetings are also held in venues such as schools, libraries and community centres to help engage service users and members of the public. 

   

  However, due to current restrictions and the requirement for social distancing, Council meetings will not be held at their usual location. Meetings of the Council will be taking place virtually and ‘attendance’ will be restricted to Members of the Council, relevant officers and any registered to speak ‘interested parties’ where appropriate.  These meetings will be streamed live via You Tube and recorded for subsequent transmission via the Council’s public website.  [View Remote Meetings procedures] 

   

  Meetings are normally held every four weeks and generally start at 6.00 p.m. (unless otherwise stated).  Details of upcoming meetings can be found by clicking the button below:

   

  Schedule of meetings

   

   

• democratic@valeofglamorgan.gov.uk